PRINCIPLE STATEMENT

Any question of Islamic personal law regarding a gift where the donor is a Muslim falls within the appellate jurisdiction of the Sharia Court of Appeal.

RATIO DECIDENDI (SOURCE)

Per Ogundare, JSC, in Usman (Deceased) v. Kareem (1994) NLC-1521993(SC) at P. 7; Paras D--E.
"Any question of Islamic personal law regarding a gift where the donor is a Muslim falls within the appellate jurisdiction of the Sharia Court of Appeal."
View Judgment

EXPLANATION / SCOPE

The Sharia Court of Appeal has appellate jurisdiction over Islamic personal law matters involving Muslims. “Islamic personal law” includes: marriage, divorce, inheritance, gifts (hibah), wills, and family relationships governed by Islamic law. The jurisdictional trigger is: (1) the subject matter involves Islamic personal law; and (2) the parties (or at least the donor in gift cases) are Muslim. Gifts by Muslims involving Islamic law principles (offer, acceptance, delivery, irrevocability) fall within this jurisdiction. This specialized appellate structure ensures: Islamic law expertise, consistent application of Sharia principles, and recognition of religious legal traditions. However, jurisdiction is appellate—the Sharia Court hears appeals from lower courts (Area Courts, Customary Courts) that initially tried the matters. Original jurisdiction over such matters lies with lower courts applying Islamic law.

CASES APPLYING THIS PRINCIPLE