Principle Statement

The test for the establishment of the identity of land is whether a surveyor can, from the record, produce an accurate plan of such land. While it is the law that a plan is not in all cases a sine qua non, some description is necessary to make a disputed land ascertainable.

Ratio Decidendi (Source)

Per Tobi, JSC, in Aremu v. Adetoro (2007) NLC-123-418-2001(SC) at p. 5; Paras B–C.

"The test for the establishment of the identity of land is whether a surveyor can, from the record, produce an accurate plan of such land. While it is the law that a plan is not in all cases a sine qua non, some description is necessary to make a disputed land ascertainable."

Explanation / Scope

The test for identifying land is whether a surveyor can produce an accurate plan from the record. While a survey plan is not always mandatory, some description must be provided to make the land ascertainable. The description must be sufficient to identify the land with certainty.

Cases Applying This Principle